Handcrafted Cookies
From Our Home to Yours
Locally Made. Lovingly Baked.
Where Duck Duck Goose Bakery Found Its Feathers
In February of 2025, Cara started Duck Duck Goose Bakery to help support her family as she prepared for the upcoming medical bills for her newborn. What began as a practical step during an uncertain season quickly became something much more meaningful.
Along the way, Cara discovered a deep love for being part of life’s most special moments. It is truly an honor for her to create the centerpiece on tables at some of the biggest events in people’s lives, from weddings to once-in-a-lifetime celebrations. Knowing her cookies are shared during those unforgettable gatherings makes every batch even sweeter.
View Our Latest Work:
Our Flock Includes:
The Ohio State University
|
Columbus Realtors
|
Prime Exteriors
|
BG Staffing
|
Comparion
|
The Ohio State University | Columbus Realtors | Prime Exteriors | BG Staffing | Comparion |
Proudly local, we partner with both individuals and businesses for events and corporate gifting.
Sweet Words from the Flock
-
Natalie Sidebottom
Cara made the absolute most adorable cookies for my recent baby shower and not only were they so cute but they tasted amazing!!! The perfect softness without that hard cookie crunch and super yummy icing. 100/10 would recommend!!
-
Erin Smith
Cara makes some of the most delicious custom cookies! Not only does she make them custom to what you want, but they taste seriously incredible. You can tell how much creativity and time she puts into all of her orders! I highly recommend for any occasion… not to mention, Cara is one of the sweetest people
-
Sallie Harre Giudice
Cara made cookies for my nieces baby shower. They were fabulous!! The decorating is so cute but the taste of the cookie is wonderful! Not too thin not too thick…they were perfect! We all loved them!
-
Ellen Giudice
Cara makes the cutest and yummiest cookies!!!! They were the perfect sweet treat for a baby shower. Cara is great, the cookies are great. Couldn’t ask for anything better
-
Joanie McCoy Wirth
Cara customized cookies for my son’s wedding rehearsal dinner and did amazing work! She was incredibly easy to work with, very communicative and was open to suggestions. And the cookies? Chef’s kiss! Duck Duck Goose Bakery will be my go-to for custom cookies in the future. Not only were they beautiful, but they were delicious! The bride, groom, friends and family were so impressed! If you’re looking to support a passionate independent baker with wicked creativity, reach out to Cara, owner of Duck Duck Goose Bakery.goes here
-
Amintha Moya
She made cookies for my nieces bday and they are stunning. Picture perfect. Love love love them.
Sweet Treats From The Nest
Custom Cookies
Handcrafted cookies designed to be the centerpiece of your event. From weddings and showers to birthdays and corporate gatherings, each order is made fresh and tailored to your theme.
Custom orders are available for events, and select themed sets are occasionally released for individual purchase.
Simple Celebration Cakes
Thoughtfully made, beautifully simple cakes perfect for intimate celebrations. We focus on clean designs and classic flavors, letting quality ingredients and careful baking speak for themselves.
Custom Cookie Cakes
A fun twist on a classic favorite. Oversized cookie cakes customized for birthdays and special occasions. While still a growing part of the bakery, early orders have been a huge success — and I’m excited to expand this offering.
Snag Some Duck Duck Goose Bakery Merch
Duck Duck Goose Bakery Hoodie
$60.00
Duck Duck Goose Bakery Long Sleeve
$35.00
Duck Duck Goose Bakery Short Sleeve
$28.00
Duck Duck Goose Bakery Crewneck
$55.00
